The Results Screen #2 - Keighley, you’ve done it again…

Welcome to The Results Screen, a series in which I just rant and rave about things in the industry that have caught my eye. Every year, the nominees for the various Game Awards categories are announced and every year there’s some kind of controversy or drama.

Last year, the issue was featuring ‘Shadow of the Erdtree’ - Elden Ring’s DLC, in the running for the Game of the Year category. Personally I didn’t mind because I could attest to the scale and quality of it but I see while some people might be mad about their favourite game not being nominated. There was also umbridge taken with the remake of Resident Evil 4 being nominated, despite it basically being it’s own game.

This year sees the return of the remake discussion due to The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time being nominated. This fails in comparison to the uproar of another nominee - Grand Theft Auto VI. There’s no doubt that it’s going to be a phenomnal game, save for some disastrous launch day issues. Problem is, the game isn’t (wasn’t) out at the time the nominations were announced.

This is the crux of the issue with The Game Awards (Beyond the oft tone deaf nature of the sound of Geoff Keighley’s bulging wallet overpowering his platitudes on layoffs) is how the awards side of the show is handled. Viewer votes are only 10% of the tally while the remaining 90% is handled by an unseen panel of however many judges. Despite the public not having played the game, the judges (presumably, who’s to say how many judges can play every game?) have.

I feel like the Game Awards have an identity crisis of trying to appeal to every type of gamer - the so called ‘Ball and Gun’ casual audience aren’t the same as a more general audience who also arent’t those who care for the Top 5 streamers or specific E-Sports teams. I suppose this is alleviated by how quickly these awards are glossed over.

So in Game of the Year, you have ‘A game from 1998’ and a game that’s technically not even out yet. The other nominees - 007 First Light, Control: Resonant and Resident Evil Requiem are all great games and while I’ve not played Phantom Blade Zero, I heard it was really good. If really have to limit to six, you’ve still got only 2 more spaces to fill and nodody is going to be happy with whatever else was chosen.

I’m seeing Xbox fans mad that Gears of War E-Day wasn’t nominated (As that game is the centre of Console War rubbish for the fans), Nintendo fans mad that Fire Emblem: Fortune’s Weave wasn’t nominated (Despite it adittedly being more niche than people care to admit). Why was Onimusha not nominated? Pragmata? My favourite game??

This discourse is always frustrating and this year seems to have made it worse than it’s ever been. There’s a simple solution to any frustrations you have about the Game Awards, and that’s to decide your favourite on your own. If you do choose to watch the show, just mute the awards and enjoy the trailers and orchestra. Maybe you’ll discover something new.

Next
Next

The Campbell Conundrum aka Designing a new SAW game